Renting Your Voice from a Robot

The Modern Greeting Card

If you spend five minutes scrolling social media or checking company updates, you’ve probably noticed the exact same generic pattern everywhere. Everything is infused with AI-speak ad nauseam in an attempt to “elevate” everyone’s writing. Why bother learning grammar, voice, or genuine storytelling when you can just prompt an AI and copy/paste your way into being an instant authority on literally any subject?

There are plenty of reasons why that’s a bad idea, but the major downside is that you lose all credibility and authenticity. The second I come across a post from a business leader, author or creator that clearly relied on AI, I immediately discard it. There are some well-known giveaways that they are using AI:

  • Negative Parallelism ("It's not X, it's Y"): Sentences structured like "It's not just a tool; it's a fundamental reimagining of how we work."

  • Rule-of-Three/Triple Countdowns: Patterns like "Not just fast. Not just efficient. Truly transformative."

  • Self-Posed Rhetorical Questions: Dropping a question and immediately answering it to manufacture fake suspense (e.g., "The result? Pure magic.")

Now, let’s all roll our eyes and let out a collective groan. It feels like half the working world decided overnight to stop talking like real people!

Every reads like a corporate Hallmark card or movie trailer, with neat paragraphs that provide some workplace lesson using word combinations that nobody would ever say out loud. Someone types a quick prompt into an AI friend, convinces themselves that it sounds profound, and blasts it out to their network.

​The jarring part is that nobody actually talks that way when you meet them in person. If you sat down with a coworker in the break room and they started giving you five bullet points on “unlocking cross-functional synergy”, you’d check their pulse. In the real world, people make clumsy mistakes, aren’t sure what to do next and mumble through their thought processes.

When people remove all of that “real talk” out of their writing, they just turn into a pop-up ad that everyone tunes out.


The Real Story

​In my book, The Excuse Index, I wrote about how we build stories to protect ourselves from looking foolish. All these copy-paste professionals are simply hiding behind an excuse: the fear of being exposed as an impostor. Those feelings of “being found out” lives in all of us to some degree. AI just gave us a digital publicist, making it so easy to hide without without ever attempting to address the root issues.

​Putting your real thoughts on paper definitely feels risky. Someone might challenge your logic, or realize you do not have all the answers. What if you misspell a word or sound less than polished? Prior to AI, the answer to that question was straightforward: learn and improve with practice.

If you post a generic paragraph generated by a robot, no one ever criticizes your thinking because there is no original thought to critique. Even if someone asks a follow-up question, you don’t need a real answer; you can just feed the question right back into the machine. If people dislike the post, you can tell yourself it was not really your voice anyway, which lets you stay hidden in your insecurity, and the cycle repeats all over again.


What Gets Lost in the Machine

​There is nothing wrong with using software to help you look up information, catch typos, or organize your notes. AI can easily fit into your daily routine to enable and improve what you do. Struggling to come up with ideas? Ask AI for some inspiration. Not sure how to build out the process for a new project? AI can provide a great outline to get you started. AI is great at augmenting what we do, but it should not replace it.

The trouble starts when you let a machine do the actual thinking for you. In simple terms, writing is the physical proof of your ability to work through a problem in your own head. When you let AI decide how you say what you believe, you give up the only thing that makes your experience valuable to other people. In consulting, I’ve watched engineers churn out slide-deck fluff in an effort to appear knowledgeable, only to see it all collapse the moment someone asks a pointed question live in the room.

​We are already starting to see the silly results of this in daily office communication. An employee uses AI to draft a long email, the manager uses AI to summarize that email, and neither person actually read or understood the real issue. Nobody learns anything, nobody solves the underlying problem, and everyone wastes time passing AI-generated text back and forth.

Real trust gets built when people share honest observations and insights gleaned from critical thinking, but the actual work needs to be done first.


Three Minute Reality Check

Using your authentic voice does not take special training. Anyone can build trust and credibility simply by observing and relaying truth about what they see on the job. Before you hit publish on your next post, newsletter, or team email, run the draft through a few simple tests:

  1. ​Read the words out loud. If you would feel weird saying the sentence to a coworker across a lunch table, take it out and rewrite it like normal speech.

  2. Be specific. AI will typically create broad generalizations that don’t fully address anything real. That time that you learned how to quickly compose yourself after spilling coffee all over your desk right before your new boss walked in the room? That’s a real experience. AI would just give a few bullet points and generic corporate lessons.

  3. ​Keep your personal voice. If you tend to be direct, stay direct. If you like using light humor, use it. People want to hear the real you (within reason of course). Personally, I’d take an unpolished real post over a “professional” fake greeting card every single time.

Next
Next

The Danger of Being Too Nice